Amish Scalloped Oysters Recipe

Serves/Makes: 4 - 5


  • 1 (10-ounce) can medium-sized oysters, drained
  • 4 cups crackers, coarsely crushed
  • 2 cups milk
  • 1 egg
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • Pepper, to taste
  • 1/3 cup butter or margarine
How to cook Amish Scalloped Oysters:
  • Line a 1 1/2-quart casserole with half of the crackers.
  • Place half of the oysters on crushed crackers. Layer remaining crackers on top of oysters followed by the rest of the oysters.
  • Beat egg and add milk, salt, and pepper.
  • Just before baking pour mixture over oysters and crackers. Arrange butter in thin slices on top.
  • Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 30 minutes.


The Amish Scalloped Oysters recipe easy to prepare and so good!


The Amish are a religious group who live in settlements in 22 of the United States and Ontario, Canada. The oldest group of "Old Order Amish," about 16-18,000 people live in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.

A scalloped (escalloped) dish generally calls for layers of the featured ingredients to be coated with cream sauce and topped with bread crumbs before baking.

This recipe for Amish Scalloped Oysters serves/makes: 4 - 5

The Amish Scalloped Oysters recipe and the pictures are adopted from The Our Favorite Fish & Seafood Recipes Cookbook.

Main Ingredient: Oysters (more Oysters recipes)
Preparation Method: Baked (more Baked recipes)
Cuisine: American (more American recipes)

More in Oysters ~ Baked recipes:

  • Oregano Oysters ~ Baked Oysters Recipe - Oysters on the half-shell coated with parsley, oregano, Pernod, and cream. If fresh oysters are not available, use fresh Mussels or clams.
  • Oysters with White Wine ~ Baked Oysters Recipe - Baked oysters on the half shell with soda cracker crumbs, bacon, and white wine.
  • Baked Oyster Dish ~ Baked Oyster Recipe - recipe how to bake oysters with bell pepper, milk, and pimientos topped with a pie shell.
  • Oysters Parmesan ~ Baked Oysters Recipe - Baked oysters on the half shell sprinkled with butter, crumbs, and Parmesan cheese.
  • Baked Parmesan Oyster with Bacon ~ Baked Oyster Recipe - recipe how to bake oysters with bacon strips, green onions, white pepper, Pernod, half and half (cream), fresh spinach, chicken bullion, Tabasco sauce, nutmeg, and Parmesan c...
  • Oyster Kilpatrick ~ Baked Oyster Recipe - easy recipe how to bake fresh oysters with garlic, bacon, grated cheese, cayenne pepper, Worchester sauce, and tomato sauce. Australian recipe.

Free Fish & Seafood Recipes

^ Back to Top